Holt Educational Consultant
Apr 25, 2020
Writing Feedback / IELTS Writing task 2: Pros and cons of private healthcare system [3]
You misunderstood the prompt requirement. This essay is not instructed to be written as an A/D essay. This essay asks an opinion question that you have to respond to:
Do the advantages of private health care outweigh its disadvantages? Pick one side to defend in the essay. Why should you pick only one side to discuss when the question asks "do the advantages... its advantages?" The answer to that question lies in the discussion instruction itself. Had the prompt asked you to accomplish the following: "Discuss the advantages and disadvantages and give a personal opinion", then you should have definitely done the A/D format discussion. Since the question asked you to pick one side, then this is a single opinion essay, not a comparison essay. So your TA approach is all wrong for the essay and will definitely pull you back from achieving a 5 band score.
Since you gave a direct response to the question, which shows you have a given opinion on the topic, the examiner will score your essay based only on the part that you wrote, which supports the stance you provided in the paraphrase. Therefore, your essay will fall under the minimum 250 word count and suffer points deductions for that. You have to learn to decipher what kind of essay you have to write in response to the given instruction or discussion recommendation. There are several ways of discussing this topic, but only one approach to the discussion question. That is the singular opinion approach.
Based on the error in your approach, I will refrain from scoring this essay. It will not achieve a satisfactory band score. I would rather score your next essay, which I hope, will show a better understanding and approach to the given discussion topic.
You misunderstood the prompt requirement. This essay is not instructed to be written as an A/D essay. This essay asks an opinion question that you have to respond to:
Do the advantages of private health care outweigh its disadvantages? Pick one side to defend in the essay. Why should you pick only one side to discuss when the question asks "do the advantages... its advantages?" The answer to that question lies in the discussion instruction itself. Had the prompt asked you to accomplish the following: "Discuss the advantages and disadvantages and give a personal opinion", then you should have definitely done the A/D format discussion. Since the question asked you to pick one side, then this is a single opinion essay, not a comparison essay. So your TA approach is all wrong for the essay and will definitely pull you back from achieving a 5 band score.
Since you gave a direct response to the question, which shows you have a given opinion on the topic, the examiner will score your essay based only on the part that you wrote, which supports the stance you provided in the paraphrase. Therefore, your essay will fall under the minimum 250 word count and suffer points deductions for that. You have to learn to decipher what kind of essay you have to write in response to the given instruction or discussion recommendation. There are several ways of discussing this topic, but only one approach to the discussion question. That is the singular opinion approach.
Based on the error in your approach, I will refrain from scoring this essay. It will not achieve a satisfactory band score. I would rather score your next essay, which I hope, will show a better understanding and approach to the given discussion topic.
